Anthony’s Cookies in the Mission Serves Up the Goods; Cookies and Cream Our Favorite


Cookies and Cream or Cookies and Crack?

If you haven’t already noticed, Hoodscope is a fan of 7×7’s Big Eat SF (although we may not always agree with them).  This year Anthony’s Cookies and Cream cookie is new on the list, so you know I had to try it.  Actually, Gene thought he would be the first Hoodscoper to try the cookie, but he was rejected twice when Anthony’s was temporarily closed.   A couple days later, we were pleasantly surprised when Anthony announced via Twitter that they would be giving out free cookies that Saturday from 1-3pm.  The third time’s a charm right? Gene decided he would give Anthony’s Cookies another shot.

Sure enough we arrived early that Saturday expecting a line, but only a handful of people were in the shop.   The clock struck 1 o’clock and an employee announced the free cookie giveaway.  He pointed to the framed list of flavors on the counter, and told us each customer would get not one, but 2 free cookies!  That was a generous offer I could not pass up.  I decided on one Cookies and Cream, one Toffee Chip, and an assortment to go.  Collectively we also tried Whole Wheat Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chip, German Chocolate, Ghirardelli White Chocolate Chip, and Cinnamon Sugar—that’s about half the menu! They rotate flavors on a daily basis, which gives us plenty of tasty reasons to keep visiting.

Opening day line

Minimum design, maximum flavor

At first glance, the storefront doesn’t appear to be anything out of the ordinary.  The space itself is very minimalist, featuring one long table and a window seat, a row of glass milk bottles on display, and an open kitchen. But the cookies are the real stars, and taste definitely outweighs presentation in this case (unlike some other dessert shops *coughcupcakescough*).  The cookies are thin and perfectly crisp on the outside, chewy and melty on the inside.  And you really can’t go wrong using all-natural ingredients from right here in San Francisco.

Toffee Chip

Cinnamon Sugar

The White Chocolate Chip and the Toffee Chip were definitely the sweetest of the bunch. The White Chocolate Chip has big chunks of chocolate and the Cinnamon Sugar definitely has more cinnamon than sugar, slightly reminiscent of a mild ginger snap.  Whole Wheat Oatmeal Chocolate Chip has a nice texture to it, chewy, but not dense like most oatmeal cookies I’ve tried.  Cookies and Cream is our favorite, hands down.  A cross between a Chocolate Chip and an Oreo cookie, it’s quite an innovative combo.  It goes especially well with a glass of Straus Creamery milk, which is some damn good milk, chunks of cream and all. Even better, paired with a cup of Ritual Coffee from down the street!

Anthony has certainly made a quick name for himself as a local favorite. And to think, 13 years ago, he was a starving SF State student peddling cookies out of the trunk of his car!  He is currently perfecting more flavors, including a vegan variety.  Stop by the shop on Valencia, or find select flavors at The Real Food Co. and Rainbow Grocery.


Anthony’s Cookies
1417 Valencia Street (between 25th & 26th Streets)
San Francisco, CA 94110
(415) 655-9834

Images: Flickr/AndersP and ChefTinaLuu, Yelp/Wilhelm Y.

Also check out:
Mitchell’s Ice Cream: A San Francisco favorite since 1953
Gelateria Naia in the Castro; All Natural Gelato
Hot Cookie in the Castro; Cookies and Penises Under One Roof
Sweet Beat: Italian Gelato (in Some Very Un-Italian Flavors) at Marco Polo
Golden Island Cafe: Hong Kong-Style Sago Sweets in the Outer Sunset


7 Responses to “Anthony’s Cookies in the Mission Serves Up the Goods; Cookies and Cream Our Favorite”

  1. 1 The IRS

    Those cookies look delicious…just like this post’s author. Haha.

  2. 2 Brad

    I love cookies! Great review! Too bad it’s not free anymore.

  3. 3 Anne

    Thanks Brad! You’re in luck… Tomorrow Coffee Bar will be giving away free Anthony’s cookies with purchase of lunch! Tell them Hoodscope sent you!

  4. Wow that Toffee Chip one looks DELISIOSO!

  5. 5 PiterJankovich

    My name is Piter Jankovich. oOnly want to tell, that your blog is really cool
    And want to ask you: is this blog your hobby?
    P.S. Sorry for my bad english

  6. 6 Gene

    Hi Piter, this blog is a passionate hobby of mine 🙂

  1. 1 Bi-Rite Creamery Soft Serve Ice Cream – I’d rather have McDonald’s « Hoodscope

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: